Blog Posts - 2023

Open Shelving vs. Closed Cabinets: Balancing Functionality & Aesthetics

Written by Carrie | Mar 5, 2025 5:47:45 PM

If there’s one question that can divide even the most harmonious of kitchen renovators, it’s this: Open shelving or closed cabinets – which is better? The truth is, both have their strengths, and the right choice often comes down to your personal style, how you use your kitchen, and yes, how much time you’re willing to spend keeping things tidy.

Whether you’re drawn to the modern, airy vibe of open shelves or the timeless functionality of closed cabinets, the decision isn’t always straightforward. In case you're not sure which direction to take, consulting an expert kitchen remodeling company in Chester County can help you weigh your options and figure out what works best for your space.

Open shelving or kitchen cabinets: which is better?

Let’s explore the pros and cons of both to help you decide which one fits you best.

Open shelving: The Instagram darling

Open shelving is like the cool kid in high school—trendy, bold, and effortlessly stylish. It’s perfect for those who want to display their curated collection of artisanal ceramics, glass jars filled with spices, or that striking copper pot reserved for special occasions.

The pros

  • Aesthetic appeal: Open shelving can make your kitchen feel brighter and more spacious. It’s a minimalist’s dream.
  • Easy access: Everything is within reach. No more rummaging for that elusive coffee mug while half-asleep.
  • Budget-friendly: Compared to custom cabinets, shelves are often more affordable and easier to install.

The cons

  • Dust & grime: Unless you’re diligent with cleaning, your exposed items might look like they’ve been on a dusty archaeological dig.
  • Visual clutter: Not everyone’s kitchen items look like they belong in a magazine spread. Open shelving demands a certain level of aesthetic discipline.

Closed cabinets: Reliable and classic

Closed cabinets are more than just the reliable backbone of your kitchen - they can easily steal the spotlight when thoughtfully designed. Custom cabinets, with their endless options for finishes, colors, and details, can command as much attention as any open shelving setup, offering both stunning aesthetics and unmatched practicality. 

Why we love them

  • Hidden storage: Cabinets are great for stashing everything from your blender and mismatched plates to that box of cereal that has somehow been there for six months.
  • Protection: Your dishes and cookware are safe from dust, grease, and curious little hands.
  • Endless options: Cabinets come in so many styles and finishes that it’s easy to find something that fits your vibe.

The not-so-great stuff

  • Pricey: Quality cabinets can eat up a chunk of your kitchen budget.
  • Can feel boxy: In smaller kitchens, too many cabinets can make the space feel closed off and heavy. However, professional help can easily prevent this.

So, which is better?

Here’s the honest answer: It depends on you. Open shelving is perfect if you love the idea of a clean, curated look and don’t mind a little extra upkeep. Closed cabinets are ideal if you prioritize ease and don’t want to worry about what your kitchen looks like on a random Tuesday. If you can’t decide, try combining the two. You get the visual interest of open shelves and the practicality of closed cabinets—a win-win.

Final thought: At the end of the day, your kitchen should work for you. It’s where life happens, whether that’s whipping up a feast or reheating last night’s pizza. Choose what feels right, and don’t overthink it. After all, it’s your kitchen, and you make the rules.

What is a top-notch kitchen remodeling company in Chester County?

Whether you prefer open shelving, traditional cabinets, or a mix of both, the key is creating a kitchen that works for you. From modern, streamlined designs to timeless, classic looks - and even family-friendly spaces that make cooking and organizing a breeze - the Kitchen Magic team has you covered. We can help you with smart organization tips, practical storage solutions, and so much more. No matter where you are in Chester County, feel free to get in touch with us to let us know what you have in mind and how we can bring it to life.